Senent-Domínguez, Rosa (2016). \"La deformación del tipo. Construcción de bóvedas no-canónicas en España (siglos XVI-XVIII)\", PhD Dissertation. Madrid: Escuela Técnica Superior de Arquitectura (UPM)

A non canonical vault is a vault adapted to a different form from that for which was originally conceived. These rare, abnormal, unconventional vaults are usually considered as exceptions or special cases. However they prove to be more frequent than it was initially expected.Interest in this type of vaults arises from an initial research on the vaults used to roof annular spaces, such as ambulatories. Nevertheless, the annular vault question cannot be addressed directly, but as a part of a broader research on distorted vaults; a research on vaults deformed to conform an anomalous layout.The analysis of the possibilities that a particular type of vault provides to solve the vaulting of an irregular layout, beyond the problem of the annular plan is the origin of this research.The argument of deformed vaults is part of a greater context, the context of deformation in vaulted architecture. Facing a contradiction, deforming a vault is just one of the options that vaulted architecture offers to solve a problem of deformation.This dissertation is organized in two parts: in the first part we analyze the concepts of form and deformation in the context of vaulted architecture in order to lay the foundations for a non canonical vaults theory. The objective is to establish a starting point for future research in a field that has not been addressed yet. In the second part, we analyze three types of vault from the perspective of non canonical vaults, based on a case study of Spanish vaults between the 16th and 18th Centuries.The analysis of deformation in vaulted architecture focuses on the question of the ambulatory, because it is a generalized example of deformation, directly related to the problem of irregular vaults. Remarkably, the analysis of these spaces had not been conducted to date. We propose a first approach to the question of the ambulatory, from a purely morphological point of view, setting aside historical considerations.The analysis of deformed vaults focuses on three types of vault: the groin vault, the ribbed vault and the sail vault. These three types of vault, although based on different formal criteria, are closely related between them. On the one hand, they allow to solve the same problem –a square perimeter limited by arcs-; on the other hand, it is possible to establish a formal relationship between the groin vault and the sail vault through the ribbed vault.The case study presented in the second part of this dissertation is based on two research lines: theoretical non conventional vaults solutions proposed on stonecutting treatises; and currently built vaults. The aim of this double analysis was to establish a comparison between theory and practice, comparing the degree of relationship between them. Nevertheless, this double analysis has only been carried out on rare occasions. It is noted that non canonical vaults reflected in treaties are few and hardly been employed, while the built solutions do not meet proposed theoretical models, expressing a divorce between theory and practice.The analysis of these vaults allows us to question the traditional definition that connects the concepts of 'vault' and 'surface'. When we began this research, we found an extremely rigid theoretical model that leaved out many vaults, forcing to group them under the term of «non canonical vaults». This research evidences the limitations of the model. The problem is not the presence of abnormal vaults, which cannot adapt to the traditional model, but in the very high stiffness of the model.