Parametric environmental climate adaptive design: the role of data design to control urban regeneration project of Borgo Antignano, Naples
Descripción
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
1G76C,A6CC>CI:8IJG: :H>C67A: :K:ADEB:CI 1, / +8ID7:G
,6G6B:IG>8:CK>GDCB:CI6A8A>B6I:696EI>K:9:H>6CD B7GDH>C>7 & '
. #2.9*56.7H=:97N!AH:K>:G (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd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
D;I:CB6G@:97NK6G>DJHHJG;68:IG:6IB:CIH 9:E:C9>CI=>CI=:JG76C ;67G>8 >I>HEDHH>7A:IDCDI>8:6G:6H>9:CI>;>:97NI=:8DCI:BEDG6GNEG:H:C8:D;=>HIDG>86A6C9BD9:GC8DCI:MIH L>I=
BDCDH9:;>C:9>CI=:">;I= HH:HHB:CI.:EDGID;%, I=:., H8:C6G>D 8DCH>9:GI=:A68@D;G:9J8I>DCD; +:B>HH>DCH 7N6C96K:G6C9JHIG>6AA:K:AH
949
950
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
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
688DG9>CDC6C9EG:K:CI>K:8=:8@>HC:8:HH6GN K:CI=: BJAI>EA>8>IND; 6HE:8IHID8DCH>9:G>CDG9:GID9:;>C:6EEGDEG>6I:9:H>DCH 86E67A:D;G:HEDC9>CK:ANIDI=:HIG:HH:HD; I=::MI:GC6A:CK>GDCB:CI6C9>BEGDK:>C9DDG8DB;DGI7N68I>C8GD8A>B6I:D;I=:6G:6>CI:GK:CI>DC %0 IDDAH ID H>BJA6I: I=: 7J>AI :CK>GDCB:CI 8DCHI>IJI: 6C :FJ>EB:CI JH:;JA ID I=: @CDLA:98GD8A>B6I>8 8DC9>I>DCHI=GDJBJA6I>DCD;I=:HI6IJHFJDD;EA68:H6C9I=:CD;I=:EGD?:8I >CDG9:GIDE:G;DGB68DBEJI:G>O:9 BDC>IDG>CCJDJH6HH:HHB:CI 6AADL>CCI>86A>HHJ:H6C9=:AE9:H>8:69:FJ6I: HDAJI>DCH 0=:HE:8>;>8>IND;I=:;:6IJG:H6C9G:HJAIHD7I6>C:97NH>BJA6I>DCHD;IL6G:;DG6G8=>I:8IJG: G:FJ>G:HI=:JH:D;B6CN HD;IL6G: L>I=I=:C::9ID:MEDGI6C9>BEDGI;>A:HIDK:G>;NI=:8=D>8:HB69: 6C9I=:C G:E:6II=:DE:G6I>DCH6;I:G E:G;DGB>CGHI8DCIGDA6C9HDDCJCI>AI=:9:;>C>I>DCD;I=:HJ>I67A:HDAJI>DC 0=>HEGD8:HH=6H7::C;68>A>I6I:97N I=: >CI:GDE:G67>A>IN 7:IL::C HD;IL6G: :K:C D; 9>;;:G:CI HD;IL6G: =DJH:H 0=: G:HJAIH D7I6>C:9 L>I=>C 9>;;:G:CI HD;IL6G: G:EG:H:CI6HIGDCBJAI6C:DJHA6H6B6II:GD;;68I:68= DJIEJI>H6E>:8:I=6I9D:HCDI>CI:G68IHL>I=I=:DI=:GH +C:D;I=:D7?:8I>K:HD;I=>HG:H:6G8=>HIDDK:G8DB:I=>H6EEGD68=>CDG9:GID8=:8@I=:EDHH>7>A>IND;:M8=6CC;DGB6I>DC7:IL::C9>;;:G:CIHD;IL6G:H>BJA6I>DC>CID6H>CCGDCB:CI 0D68=>:K:I=>HI6GIL6H 9:8>9:9 ID JH: I=: HD;IL6G: .=>CD8:GDH 6H IG>9>B:CH>DC6A BD9:A>CGDCB:CI L>I= I=: 6AI=B>8 :9>IDG#G6HH=DEE:G;DGE6G6B:IG>8BD9:A>C< L=>8=>HJH:;JA>CDG9:GIDEGDK>9:6EA6I;DGB;DG96I6:M8=6C;;:G:CIHD;IL6G:6H JID9:@Q!8DI:8IQ C6ANH>H !CK> )!0 6C9B6CN#G6HH=DEE:G^HEAJ< >C(69N7J<
#:8D '6CII=:>CI:GDE:G67>A>IN7:IL::CHD;IL6G:6C9BJA6I>DCH 6C6ANH>H6C9G:HJAIH >CID6H>CGDCB:CI CN8=6CI=>C.=>CD B6@:EDHH>7A:ID JE96I:H:B> 6JIDB6I>86AANI=:G:HJAIHL>I=DJIE:G;DGB:MEDGI6C9>BEDGID;;>A:H 0=:EDHH>7>A>INIDDE:G6I:>CHI6CI K:G>;>86I>DC6C9>BEA:B:CI8DCIGDAHD;E:G;DGB6C8:>C6H>CGDCB:CI ;GDB9>;;:G:CIHD;IL6G: 6AADLHIDD7I6>C 68A:6G6C9JC>KD86AG:69>CCJH:;JA>C9>86I>DCHIDDE:G6I:BDG: G:HEDCH>K:9:H>8:HIDI=::CK>GDCB:CI6A8DC9>I>DCH 0=:B:I6 9:H>8=9:G>K:H;GDBI=:9:H>HI=:G:HJAID;G:H:6G8= H>BJA6I>DC6C9 6C6ANH>H86GG>:9DJIDCI=:HI6IJHFJDD;I=:HIJ9N6G:6 ;>GHIHI:EIDL6G9HI=:>9:CI>;>86I>DCD;I=::A:B:CIHI=6I8=6G68I:G>O:I=:JHAD8>>H JC9DJ7I:9AN I=:HIJ9ND; I=:DG>CHD;I=:GJG6A=>AAH>9:K>AA68= I=GDJ:H =6H6HHJB:9I=:GDA:D;8GDHHGD69HD; 2DB:GD>CI=:JG76CEA6CC>C<
"JC8I>DC6A HE6I>6A6C6ANH>H>CK:HI>6A>HI7J>A9>CGG:A6I>DCH=>EHL>I=I=:GD69 A6NDJI
JG76C6C99:H>HD;=>HIDG>86AB6EHG:K:6A:96HI=:BDGE=DAD86A8=6G68I:GHD;I=:K>AA6CI=:G:8:CIJG76C;67G>8 0=:K6AJ:I6@:C;GDB=>HIDGN IG6CH;DGBHI=:H:E:8JA>6G>I>:H6H>CK6G>6CIH D;I=:EGD?:8II=6II=:9:H>AAEG:H:GK:>C=>H9:H>86C9I:8=CDAD86A8=6G68I:G>HI>8HD;I=: JG76CHE68: 7:8DB:I=:HI6GI>CCID;I=:EGDEDH:9B:I=D9DAD86A 8=6G68I:G>HI>8H D; I=: B6I:G>6AH HJ8= 6H 6A7:9D :B>HH>K>IN :I8 067A: 6C9 I=: :CK>GDCB:CI6A ;:6IJG:H HJ8=6H9>G:8I6C99>;;JH:9HDA6GG69>6I>DC C6IJG6A K:CI>A6I>DC6C9H=69>C67A:HI=6I 8=6G68I:G>O:I=:JG76CHE68: I=6II=GDJDC6C9I=:B6I:G>6AHI=:N6G:B69:D; 9:I:GB>C: I=: G:HEDCH:I=6II=:HE68:>H67A:IDEGDK>9:I=GDJ;>8H>BJA6I>DCH 7:;DG:6C96;I:GI=:EGD?:8I 067A: ,6K:B:CIHB6I:G>6AHJH:9;DGI=:H>BJA6I>DCH %
)6I:G>6A
A7:9D
!B>HH>K>IN
/.%
.DJ8HIDC:
ED
,DG;>9D
EG
.:6HH:B7A:9A6K>8HIDC:
H
E=6AI
E
,6K:B:CI8DC8G:I:
H
HE=6AI DDA#G>D
C8
*6IJG6A8=6G8D6A
67
HE=6AI7AD8@
=
.:6HH:B7A:98:B:CI
9J
1$,
0DG:68=I:8=CDAD86A6C9:CK>GDCB:CI6AH>BEA>;>86I>DC6C98A6HH>;>86I>DCD;I=::A:B:CIHI=6IB69:JEI=:JG76C HE68: L:=6K:IG>:9ID:C8D9:I=:B>C96I6 >C;DGB6I>DC HDI=6II=:N 7:8DB:E=NH>86AK6G>67A:H67A:ID8=6G68I:G>O: I=:9DB6>CL>I=>CI=:9:H>AAEGDK>9:9:H>I>K:IDI=:EGD7A:BH86JH:97N A>B6I: =6CO>C67A:H :K:CH>BEA>;>:96C9A>B>I:9>CHE:8>;>86G:6H >HI=:;>GHIEGD8:9JG6AD7HI68A: 0=: H:8DC9DC:>HI=:;G6C;DGB6I>DCI=6II=:9:H>K:H6HI=:G:HJAID;H>BJA6I>DCH;GDB BJAI>EA:%0IDDAH %I>H:K>9:CII=:;JGI=:G8DBEA>86I>DCD;I=:EGD7A:B IA6HI >;>IL:G:EDHH>7A:IDH::=DLI=:H: >C;DGB6I>DC8DCIG>7JI:IDI=:9:8>H>DC B6@>CC8;ADL8=6GI">< >IL>AA7:8DCH>9:G:9 696I69:H>CGIJ6A LDG@:CK>GDCB:CI=6H6AADL:9IDDK:G8DB:I=:;G6DCD;>C;DGB6I>DC 6C9 IDL6G9H6C6IJG6ADG>:CI6I>DCID6E6G6B:IG>86C96AI=B>86EEGD68=;DGI=:DEI>B>O6I>DCD;I=:BJAI>EA:>C;DGB6I>DC ;>8H>BJA6I>DCH
">< /NCDEI>8;ADL8=6GI 3DG@;ADL9:;>C>I>DC
951
952
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
0=:K>GIJ6ALDG@EA68:=6H7::C>9:CI>;>:9>C.=>CD8:GDHHD;IL6G:.$;DG BD9:A>CA>IN D;.$>H8:GI6>CANI=:G:HJAID;I=:>CI:DCL>I=I=:HD;IL6G:#G6HH=DEE:G#$ 0=>HEAJ< >C6AADLHJHID69DEI6E6G6B:IG>86C96AI=B>86EEGD68= 8JHIDB>O>CDCHE:G;DGB6C8:9DC I=:;ADLD;>C;DGB6I>DC6C9 DG D7?:8IH 6C9IDB6@:K>H>7A:I=:EGD8:HH>CC.$ BD9:A6C996I686C8D:M>HI >C6H>CGDCB:CI>CL=>8=I=:9:H>DJHINE:HD;>C;DGB6I>DC 1H>C86EEGD68= 6H6E6GID;I=:6G8=>I:8IJG6A6C9JG76C9:H>BEGDK:HI=:9:H>I;68:9>H8G:I>O:9>HHJ:H>CI:GBHD;CJB7:GH6C9E:G;DGB6C8:>C9:M:H6C9 BDG: ;I=:EGDEDH6ABJHI G:HEDC9IDHE:8>;>89:H>;N 0=:E6G6B:IG>89:H>I:8IJG6A9G6L>CI6AADLHID86GGNDJII=: 9:H>CIGDHE:8I>DC %I >H 8:GI6>CAN JH:;JA ID G:86AA I=: ;DAADL>CC>I>DCHID;JGI=:G8A6G>;NI=:C6IJG:D;I=: B:I=D9DAD86A6EEGD68=9:H8G>7:967DK: AI=B>8BD9:A>H6CDE:G6I>CHI>CC>I:CJB7:GD;>CHIGJ8I>DCH ,6G6B:IG>8BD9:A>H6C6AI=B>8BD9:A>CL=>8=6IA:6HI6E6G6B:I:G>H>CIGD9J8:9 6C9DCL=>8=>I>HEDHH>7A: ID8=6CIHK6AJ:>C>CEJIE=6H:
%35/+03: 0=:DE:G6I>DCHL:=6K:B69: 6;I:GI=:EGD7A:BH:MEDH:967DK: 86C7:9>K>9:9>CIDI=:;>K:HI:EH7:ADL
)D9:AA>CDC H>BJA6I>DCD;:CK>GDCB:CI6A 6C6ANH>H *JB:G>86ABD9:AA>C< B>8GD8A>B6I:H>BJA6I>DC6C98DC;>DC %BEDGI>CDC6C98DBE6G>HDCD;G:HJAIH 0=:H6B:EGD8:HHL6H;DAADL:9;DGI=:;DGBJA6I>DCD;I=:EGD?:8IEGDEDH6A
3)*00.2,7-*678)GHIHI:EL6HID8G:6I:6 BD9:AD;I=:HIJ9N6G:6 B6@>CCH>IJ7NI=:HJEEDGID;D;;>8>6A86GIDC ;DGB6I EGDK>9:97NI=:)JC>8>E6A>IND;*6EA:H 0=:G:6A>O6I>DC D;I=:BD9:AL6HB69:>C.$ L=>8==6HHE::9:9 JEI=:76H>8DE:G6I>DCHD; BD9:AA>C< )D9:AA:9JG76C6G:6H >C8AJ9:,>6OO69: GI>HI> ,>6OO:II6 DG6 CC:AA6 >)6HH>BD 2>6#>D688=>CD.DHH>C>">< 0=:6AI>B:IGND;I=:HIJ9N6G:6L6H>BEDGI:9L>I= I=:6EEGDEG>6I:.$EAJ< >C (6C9H :H> /
I=GDJ7A:
">< 6,>6OO69: GI>HI>7 DG6 CC:AA6 >)6HH>BD9 2>6#>D688=>CD.DHH>C>
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
29.5321*27&0 &2&0C8>9:CI HDA6G G69>6I>DC 6C9 >CHDA6I>DC HJCA>C:EL;DGB6I!C:GCBJA6I>DCH8DBE6G:9IDI=:6C6ANH>H HD;IL6G: JID9:H@Q!8DI:8IQ C6ANH>H /I6GI>CC6A 9:;>C:9 6AI=B >C #$ 29.5321*27&0 2&0DJHAN :MEDH:9 6EEGD68= L:L:G:67A:ID8JHIDB>O:I=:6AI=BEGDEDH:97N9>;;:G:CI>6I>C6I>DC 9>G:8I6C99>;;JH:
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
73,- =6H7::C8JHIDB>O:9IDK>:L;ADLK:8IDGHL>I=>CI=: BD9:AK>H>7A: 6GG>:9DJI 6;>GHI96I6:M8=6CDCD; " 6C6ANH>HG:HJAIHL>I=>C.$:CK>GDCB:CI >I >HEDHH>7A:IDHIJ9N >CI=: BD9:AI=:7:=6K>DGD;I=:C6IJG6AK:CI>A6I>DC >9:CI>;N>CH69K6CI6BJA6I>DCD;B>8GD8A>B6I>88DC9>I>DCHD;I=:6C6ANH:9 6G:6H 7N 69DEI>CHI>8 H>BJA6I>DC HD;IL6G: !CK> )!0 0=: :M8=6CBJA6I:9 G:HJAIH >H HJ7?:8I:9 ID CJB:G>86ABD9:AA>CC6A96I676H: I=6I9:H8G>7:HI=:8JGG:CIHI6I:D; I=:EA68:H6C9I=:C D;I=:EGD?:8IEGDEDH6AH 0=:HI:EH9:H8G>7:967DK:L:G:E:G;DGB:9L>I=>CI=:FJDI:9HD;IL6G: 6C986C7:9>K>9:9>CID;>K:HI:EH
*JB:G>86ABD9:AA>CA9>CC< K:DC /:II>CA:8DC;>DCIDGJCH>BJA6I>DC .JCC>CBJA6I>DCH G:6I>C< 96I6I67A:H8DCI6>C>CBJA6I>DCH 2>:L>CCCC!CK> )!0 >IL6HEDHH>7A:ID:MIG68II=:G:HJAIH>C6I67JA6G ;DGB6I6C9>BEDGII=:B I=GDJC(JC8=7DM >C#$ 6II=::C9D;I=:H>BJA6I>DCH 86GG>:9DJI>CI=:=DII:HI 96N:ME:8I:9>CI=:8A>B6I:;>A:I= JC6A6AI=B9:;>C:9 $73,- >C8AJ9:HI=:BD9:AA>CK:CJB7:G D;;68:H688DBEA>H=I=:H6B:;JC8I>DCD;86A8JA6I>DC8:AAHJH:97N!CK> ):I H>BJA6I>DCH 0=:G:;DG: 6IDDA86AA:9 !357.2,*006 L6HEGD88DCHIGJ8IH IDG:6HH>DCD;;68:H>CI=: B:H= 688DG9>CCFJ: 6HH>BJA6I:9 G:HJAIH 0=GDJ7A:ID>BEGDK:I=:DJIEJID;JH:;JAE6G6B:I:GH HJ8=6H):6C .69>6CI 0:BE:G6IJG: .:A6I>K: $JB>9>IN ,DI:CI>6A 0:BE:G6IJG: 6C9 3>C9 /E::9 B6@>CBB:9>6I:AN 6K6>A67A: :68=DC:>CID698:AA HE::9>CC6I>DCD;:K6AJ6I>DC>C9:M:HD;8A>B6I>88DB;DGI ,!06C9 ,)2 ;DG HE:8>;>8 6G:6H 0=: >BEGDK:B:CI D; I=: DJIEJI >H >CI:C9:9 ;DG I=: 9:;6JAI BD9: 9>HEA6N>C9:9 7N (:DC6G9D!CK> )!0BD9JA:
6I6:M8=6CHI=:EGD8:HHD;I6@>CCI>CID96I6HIGJ8IJG:9JC9:G6I6GDCD;I=:HDJG8:96I6
953
954
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
0=>H6EEGD68==6H:C67A:9ID6HH:HH6C98DBE6G:I=:G:HJAIH 6AADL>CCK:HI>DCD;86JH:6C9 :;;:8I I=GDJ9:CI>;>86I>DCD;I=:KJAC:G67>A>INHNHI:B67DJII=:HI6I:D;I=:6G:6H6C9 8DCH:FJ:CIAN JH:>I6H 9:8>H>DCHJEEDGI>CI=:;DGBJA6I>DCE=6H:D;I=:9:H>;>86I>DCE=6H: ;DGI=:6HH:HHB:CID;I=:EGD?:8IEGDEDH6AIDG:H>A>:C8: I=GDJB6I: ;>A:H 3DGA93:6I=:G#:C 9:K:ADE:9 7N I=: 1C>K:GH>IN D; /DJI=6BEIDC L: H>BJA6I:9 I=:DG:I>86AAN
8A>B6I>8 8DC9>I>DCH G:EDGI>CC;DGB6I>DC D; N:6G >C !CK> )!0 ;DG I=: :M:8JI>DC D; B>8GD8A>B6I>8 H>BJA6I>DCH 0=:L:6I=:GDCBD9JA:67DK: 6AADLH 7NBDGE=>CC688DG96C8:L>I=$>HH>DCHH8:C6G>DH;GDBI=:%, 0=:6AI=B>86EEGD68=L6H6AHD;DAADL:9;DGI=:8G:6I>DCD;HE:8>6A86A8JA6I>DCIDDAH9:;>C:97NI=:G:DCH ;DG.:9J8>CA9>CA>IND;I=:HD>AH>CHIJ9>:9JG76C6G:6H AHDL6H8D9:9I=: 6AI=B;DGI=:9:;>C>I>DCD;:8DAD86AK6AJ:9:;>C:97NI=:I:8=C>86AG:DCHD; >DIDE: G:6"68IDG "
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
L=>8=H:GK:HID8:GI>;NI=:FJ6A>IND;I=:7J>A9>CCI:GK:CI>DC8DBE6G:9IDI=:E:GB:67>A>IND;I=:HD>A6C9C6AAN I=6C@HIDI=:JH:D;K:8D9:H I=:JG76C9:H>6OO69: GI>HI>=6H7::C >BEGDK:9>C6E:GHE:8I>K:D;E6G6B:IG>88A>B6I:696EI>K::CK>GDCB:CI6A9:H>CK:E6II:GCL=DH: BDGE=DADHI=:G:HJAID;I=:86EIJG:9HDA6GG69>6I>DC7NI=:6C6ANH:96G:6
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
">< 6 G:6:MEDH:9ID:M8:HH>K:I=:GB6AHIG:HH7/=69>CC:H
955
956
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
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
I=GDJI=76H>88:AAD;MB %9:CI>;>86I>DCD;E:6@K6AJ:H;DG:68=G:DC. . . G:FJ>G>CCG:A6I>DCIDI=:B6M>BJB K6AJ: 6C9IG68@>C6I>K:;AJM>HD8JGK: E6N6II:CI>DCIDK:>CI:GEDA6I>DC .:9J8I>DC>CH86A:D;I=::BEINHFJ6G:H>O:8DBE6G:9IDI=:76H>88:AAIDD7I6>CE:9:HIG>6CHIG>EHA:C9: 8DGG:HEDC9>CBJBE:G8:CI6:9ID>CI:GDCB:CI6A8=6G68I:G>HI>8HD;I=:H>I:>CI=:EGD8:HHD;6G8=>I:8IJG6A9:H>C< 6C 696EI>K: 9:H>C I=: ;DGB ID I=: G:FJ:HI D; B>I>DC D; 8A>B6I: 6AI:G>CDCD;9:H>CI:GBHD;9:H>IHK:G>;>86I>DC >H9:;>C:9HI6GI>CHD; L=>8=L:9:;>C:6=6G99:H>B>O:I=:G:HJAIH;>M:9DCEG:9:I:GB>C:99:H>C>BJBID:CHJG:8:GI>;>86I:6GDJC9 I=::8DAD86A6G:6>HBSDCBSD;IDI6AA6C96G:6 A>B6I>88DB;DGI>C9>86IDGH 9:A>C:6I:6H>IJ6I>DCID=>K6A:CIID,!0 B6M R I=:DG:I>86A,!0 B:9 R
6@>CHI=:EGD8:HHI=6IL>AAB6@:K>H>7A:6C9:9>I67A:I=: D7?:8IH E6G6B:IG>86AANBD9:A:9>C#G6HH=DEE:G >CID.=>CD8:GDH
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
0=:%, H8:C6G>DG:;:G:C8:7:C8=B6G@ G:IJGCH6EDI:CI>6AHJBB:GI:BE:G6IJG:ID R 7:;DG:68I>DC EA6CC>CH 6>B:9 CDI DCAN 6I I=: 8DCIGDA 6C9 K:G>;>86I>DC D; G:HJAIH I=6I LDJA9 7: EDHH>7A: 68=>:K: 7JI:MEG:HH:H>IHK6A>9>IN>CI:GBHD;>C;AJ:C8:>CI=:9:8>H>DC B6@>CI=>C6H>CGDCB:CI 9>;;:G:CIEGD8:HH:H7N:HI67A>H=>CA>IN6H;JC8I>DCD;I=: 9:H>K:H 88DG9>CDC L:G:9NC6B>86AAN9:;>C:97:C8=B6G@HD7I6>C>CCHCDL I=:G:;DG:67A:ID:CHJG:I=:B>C>BJBA:K:AD; G:8DG9>CBEGDK:B:CI D;I=:E:GB:6I>CIND;HD>AH6;;:8I>CH 9:H>DC=6H6D;CB6I:ANBSD;K6A:CI6G:6D;IG::H>H67DJIBS BSBDG:I=6CI=:HI6IJHFJD 0=: ">C9:M>H :M8AJ9>C7JI>DCHD;>CI:GK:CI>DCHDC7J>A9>CCBEA:B:CI:9>C " .%!86A8JA6IDG6CDEI>DCID6HH:HH6B>C>BJBE:G8:CI6CI:GK:CI>DCDCI=:GDD;IDEHDC >IL6HEDHH>7A:IDI6@:CDI:D;I=:;::9 ;DGL6G9I=6IIDDAEGDK>9:H IDK:G>;N>CC< D7?:8I>K:H 0G:6I>CAI6G:6GDJ< 6/I6IJHFJD7/D;I9:H>DC8$6G99:H>DC9,!0H86A:
%BEGDK>C86AAN I=: I:8=CDAD86A 8=D>8:H D; B6I:G>6AH JH:9 ;DG I=: =6G9 9:H>BEGDK: 696EI67A: 9:H>:K:9G:HJAIH6G: 0=:>C9:M.%! 68=>:K:HI=:K6AJ:D;:M8:AA:C8:6H:ME:8I:97NI=:G:A6I>K:A:HA6I>DC 0=:9:H>:K:I=:E:G8:CI6I=I=:HI6IJHFJD 0=::FJ>K6A:CI6G:6D;IG::H>H6EEGDM>B6I:AN BS BSI=6CHD;IDEI>DC BSI=6CI=:HI6IJHFJD 0=:>C9:M " 99>I>DC6AC8G:6H:I=:H:G:HJAIH 0=:68IJ6A:8DAD86A6G:6 D7I6>C:9>H67DJIBS BSI=6CHD;IDEI>DC BSBDG:I=6CI=:HI6IJHFJD A>B6I>88DB;DGII:C9HBDG:IDL6G9H6HI6I:D;8DB;DGI B>A9I=:GB6AHIG:HHL>I=6,)2 :FJ>K6A:CIID ,!0B6M R I=:DG:I>86A,!0B:9 R K:G>;N>CBEGDK:B:CI>CI:GBHD;I:BE:G6IJG:G:9J8I>DC 8DBE6G:9IDI=:68IJ6AHI6I:
957
958
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
0=:>BEGDK:B:CI>CI:GBHD;EDI:CI>6AI:BE:G6IJG:,DI 0>HB6GC6A8DBE6G:9IDI=:HD;I9:H>DC">< 0=:G:HEDCH:IDI=>H7:=6K>DG>HID7:;DJC9>CI=:=DA>HI>8C6IJG:D;EGD7A:B 6C9I=:C DC69?68:CIJG76C6G:6HIDI=: 9:H>I:L=:G:L:8=DH:CDIID>CI:GK:C: 3:9:9J8:9I=:C::9D;BDC>IDG>CB6I:8=6CC8>CK:68I>DCDCI=:JG76CHE68:>CDG9:GID9:GB6GCHD;>BEGDK:B:CI 0=:JG76CG:C:L6AEGD?:8I;DG DG9:G:9I=:EGD7A:BHD; A>B6I: =6CC>CBEA>8>I G:A6I>DCH=>E 7:IL::C I:8=CDADI:8IJG: 6C9 I=: B:I=D9 6H DG>C D; 6 8DBEGDB>H: 7:IL::C JH:G G:FJ>G:B:CIH JG76CHE68:E:G;DGB6C8:6C9:CK>GDCB:CI6A8DC9>I>DCH
">< 6/I6IJHFJD7/D;I9:H>DC8$6G99:H>DC9,DI:CI>6A0:BE:G6IJG:H86A:
0=:B:I=D9DAD7:96C9JH:9>CI=>HG:H:6G8= >H9>G:8IID8:CIG6A>O:I=:6C6ANI>86A 9:H>CID6 H>CGDCB:CI 6C9 ID I=: H:B> 6JIDB6I>DC D; I=: G:8JGH>K:AN EGD8:HH ;DG I=: 9:;>C>I>DC D; 9:H>DCH 0=:EDHH>7>A>INIDD7I6>C6C96C6ANO:G:HJAIH;GDBB6CNHD;IL6G: IDDAH6C9EAJ< >C IDH:6G8=;DGHE:8>;>8 6HE:8IH JH:;JA ID 6C =DA>HI>8 :CK>GDCB:CI6A HIJ9N 6AADL ID 9:;>C: 69 =D8 HDAJI>DCH ID I=: JG76C HE68: D; DGI>H>CB6I: =6CC699>I>DCIDG:9J8:I=: =:6I>HA6C9:;;:8I L>I=H>;>86CI:CK>GDCB:CI6A7:C:;>IHDCI=:I=:GB6A8DB;DGIE:G8:>K:97NJH:GH6C9 >CE6GI>8JA6G
I=DH:7:ADCCH69K6CI6K:EA6N:G>CIDI=:B:I=D9DAD86AEGD8:HH >H6HH>6I:I:8=C>86A6C99:H>8:H>CI:GBHD;696EI6I>DC6C9B>I>DCD;8A>B6I:8=6CCI=:JG76C :CK>GDCB:CI I=GDJCEA:DJIEJI G:HJAI>CHD;I=:HI6IJHFJD;>GHI6C9 I=:CD;9:H>K:H 0=:9:H>C:HI=:HE68:H6C9I=::A:B:CIHI=6I8DBEDH:>I )6I:G>6AH;DG=DG>ODCI6A HJG;68:H I=:JH:D;K:DC HDAJI>DCH;DGI=:H=69>CGG69>6I:96G:6H6C9I=:E:GB:67>A>IND;I=:HD>AH 6G:8=DH:C>CDG9:GID68=>:K:I=:;>M:9D7?:8I>K:H 0=:8DCIGDA6C9I=:K:G>;>86I>DCD;I=:EGD?:8I>H86GG>:9DJI>C G:;:G:C8:IDI=:7:C8=B6G@9:;>C:97NG:;:G:C8:>C9>86IDGH 6C9I=:CB6@:6C6HH:HHB:CID;I=:9:A>:C8: D;I=:EGD?:8IID;JIJG:8A>B6I:8DC9>I>DCH 0=:LDG@;ADLD;DE:G6I>DCH86C7:8DB:69:;DG9:H>869B>C>HIG6I>DCH6C9HI6@:=DA9:GH >CDG9:GID 86GGN DJI 6HH:HHB:CIH D; EGD?:8IH ;DG I=: DE:C HE68: 6C9 I=: G:6A 69:FJ68N D; I=: EGDEDH:9 D7?:8I>K:H ;DG I=: >BEGDK:B:CID;:CK>GDCB:CI6A8DB;DGI>C6CI>8>E6I>DCD;I=::;;:8IHD;8A>B6I:8=6CGBI=:K6A>9>IND;I=:B:I=D9DAD86AEGD8:HH6C98DBEA>6C8:L>I=I=:D7?:8I>K:H;>M:9>CI=>H HIJ9N L>I=I=:EDHH>7>A>INID9:;>C:I=:76H>H;DG;JIJG:9:K:ADEB:CIH6C9:ME6C9I=:G:H:6G8=D7?:8I>K:H )DG:DK:G
>I>H:HH:CI>6AID>BEA:B:CII=:>C;DGB6I>DCD;I=:HE:8>;>8B>8GD8A>B6I>88DC9>I>DCH I=GDJCHIGJB:CI6ABDC>IDG>C< >CH>IJI=:GBDHIJG: EHN8=GDB:I:G %.I=:GBDB:I:G 6C:BDB:I=:G :I8 >CDG9:GIDD7I6>C6C6ANH>H;GDB H>BJA6I>DCH8ADH:GIDG:6A8DC9>I>DCH %CI=:;JIJG: L:6>BIDG:EA>86I:I=:EGD8:HH;DG9>;;:G:CIE6GIHD;I=:8>INL>I=9>;;:G:CIE=NH>86A6C9BDGE=DAD86A 8=6G68I:G>HI>8H HDGID;H6BEA>CC:HE:8>;>868I>DCHD;B>I>DC6C9696EI6I>DCID ;JIJG:G6>H>CG:8>IN 0=>H:MI:CH>DCD;I=:B:I=D9B6NEGDK>9:;DGI=:JH:D;#%/ EA6I;DGBH;DGI=:8DAA:8I>DC6C9 I=:9>;;JH>DC 7N6C6ADC:9 6C9>C699>I>DCL>I= %)EGD8:HH:H
Eduardo Bassolino and Luciano Ambrosini / Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 216 (2016) 948 – 959
;DGI=:8DCIGDAD;>CI:GC6AE:G;DGB6C8:D;I=:7J>A9>C8GD8A>B6I>88DC9>I>DCH8=6CHI>8 EGD8:HH L=>8=>CKDAK:I=::CI>G:JG76C6G:6 86C 7:6JH:;JAIDDA;DGI=:AD86A69B>C>HIG6I>DC6C99:H>BJA6I: 6C99:;>C:6EEGDEG>6I:HDAJI>DCH;DG696EI6I>DC6C9B>I>DCD;;JIJG:8A>B6I>88DC9>I>DCH 0=:HIJ9N>HE6GID;I=:G:H:6G8=DC>CCDK6I>K:I:8=CDAD:H;DGB>I>DC6C9696EI6I>DCID8A>B6I:8=6CCI=: 8DCI:MID;JG76CHE68:D;I=:8>I>:HD; 6BE6C>6 ;D8JH:9DCI=: >IND;*6EA:H 3>I=>CI=:G:H:6G8=I= :CK>GDCB:CI6A 9:H>B6I: 8=6C . \ :E6GIB:CI D; G8=>8IJG: D; 1C>K:GH>IN D; *6EA:H ":9:G>8D%% HE:8>6AI=6C@HD(DH6HHD 8DDG9>C6IDG6C9B:CIDG AHDI=6C@HIDI=:69B>C>HIG6I>DCD;I=: >IND;*6EA:H L=DHJDCH696EI>K:8A>B6I: I=:LDG@9DC:;DGI=:6G:6D; DG/>HI:B>!9>IDG>6A> 1* $ %0 0 >I>:H6C9 A>B6I: =6CGD7> ':CN6 1* $67>I6I
959
Lihat lebih banyak...
Comentarios
