How Criminal System Racial Disparities May Translate into Health Disparities



#RIMINALJUSTICEANDHEALTHDISPARITIES

(OW#RIMINAL3YSTEM2ACIAL$ISPARITIES-AY 4RANSLATEINTO(EALTH$ISPARITIES -ARTIN9)GUCHI 0H$ *AMES"ELL 2AJEEV.2AMCHAND 4ERRY&AIN -! -3 !BSTRACT$ISADVANTAGEDRACIALANDETHNICMINORITIESINTHE53ARESTRIKINGLYOVER REPRESENTED INTHEJUVENILEJUSTICEANDADULTCRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEMS4HISPAPERBRIEmYREVIEWSTHEEXTENT OF OVER REPRESENTATION ATTRIBUTABLE PRIMARILY TO DRUG OFFENSES AND AN EARLIER CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORKINTRODUCEDBY)GUCHIANDCOLLEAGUESSHOWINGHOWTHEUSEOFINCARCERATIONASAKEY DRUGCONTROLTOOLHASDISPROPORTIONATELYAFFECTEDTHEHEALTHANDWELLBEINGOFRACIALANDETHNIC MINORITYCOMMUNITIES7ETHENPROVIDEOBSERVATIONSFROMTHElELDTHATDEMONSTRATEHOW THEIMPLEMENTATIONOFAQUALITYASSESSMENTAPPROACHMIGHTBEUSEDTOMITIGATEPROCEDURAL STRUCTURALBIASESTHATCONTRIBUTETODISPARITIESINMINORITYCONlNEMENT ANDULTIMATELY TO REDUCEDISPARITIESINACCESSTORESOURCESANDHEALTHCARE +EYWORDS$ISPROPORTIONATEMINORITYCONlNEMENT JUVENILEJUSTICE DRUGOFFENDERS PRISON ADMISSIONS DRUGABUSE HEALTHDISPARITIES DRUGPOLICY QUALITYASSESSMENT

"

ETWEENAND THEREPORTEDNUMBEROFDRUGOFFENDERSENTERINGPRISON INTHE53EACHYEARINCREASEDFROMAPPROXIMATELY n INnTO ARELATIVELYSTABLERATEOFABOUT DRUGOFFENDERENTRIESPERYEARINn &IGURESHOWSTHISLARGEINCREASE ADJUSTEDFORTHENUMBEROFADULTSRESIDINGINTHE REPORTINGCOUNTIESn4HENUMBERSINCREASEDDRAMATICALLYIN THEYEARFORMER 3PEAKEROFTHE(OUSE 4HOMAS0HILLIPh4IPv /.EILL ANNOUNCEDAh7ARON$RUGSv )N THEREWEREAPPROXIMATELYADULTSENTERINGPRISONONADRUGOFFENSEFOR EVERY ADULTSINTHEPOPULATION"Y THISRATEHADINCREASEDMORETHAN  FOLDTOPER ADULTS &IGURESHOWSTHEREPORTEDNUMBEROFINDIVIDUALSENTERINGPRISONFORAFELONY DRUG OFFENSE EACH YEAR FROM n BY RACE -OST OF THE INCREASE IS IN THE NUMBEROF"LACKSENTERINGPRISONEACHYEARONADRUGOFFENSE4HEDISPROPORTIONS INMINORITYPRISONENTRIESFORDRUGOFFENSESARESTRIKING PARTICULARLYFORADULT"LACK -!24).)'5#()ISA0ROFESSORATTHE5NIVERSITYOF#ALIFORNIA ,OS!NGELES 3CHOOLOF0UBLIC(EALTHIN THE$EPARTMENTOF#OMMUNITY(EALTH3CIENCESANDAN!DJUNCT3ENIOR"EHAVIORAL3CIENTISTATTHE2!.$ #ORPORATION $RUG0OLICY2ESEARCH#ENTER WHERE4%229&!).ISA3ENIOR2ESEARCH!NALYST*!-%3"%,, ISTHE&OUNDERAND%XECUTIVE$IRECTOROF4HE7(AYWOOD"URNS)NSTITUTEFOR*UVENILE*USTICE&AIRNESSAND %QUITYIN3AN&RANCISCO2!*%%62!-#(!.$ISADOCTORALCANDIDATEAT4HE*OHNS(OPKINS5NIVERSITY "LOOMBERG3CHOOLOF0UBLIC(EALTH0LEASEADDRESSCORRESPONDENCETO$R)GUCHIAT2!.$ $RUG0OLICY 2ESEARCH#ENTER -AIN3TREET 0/"OX -7 3ANTA-ONICA #! 

*OURNALOF(EALTH#AREFORTHE0OORAND5NDERSERVED n

)GUCHI "ELL 2AMCHANDAND&AIN



&IGURE2ATEOFYEARLYPRISONADMISSIONSFORADRUGOFFENSEPER ADULTS 3OURCE OF DATA "UREAU OF *USTICE 3TATISTICS .ATIONAL #ORRECTIONS 2EPORTING 0ROGRAM 7ASHINGTON $# 53 $EPARTMENT OF *USTICE   2ETRIEVED!PRIL   FROM .ATIONAL!RCHIVEOF#RIMINAL*USTICE$ATA )NTER UNIVERSITY#ONSORTIUMFOR0OLITICALAND3OCIAL 2ESEARCH 5NIVERSITYOF-ICHIGAN52,HTTPWWWICPSRUMICHEDU.!#$*ARCHIVEHTML

&IGURE.UMBEROFREPORTEDADMISSIONSTOPRISONFORADRUGOFFENSE BYRACEETHNICITY 3OURCE OF DATA "UREAU OF *USTICE 3TATISTICS .ATIONAL #ORRECTIONS 2EPORTING 0ROGRAM 7ASHINGTON $# 53 $EPARTMENT OF *USTICE   2ETRIEVED!PRIL   FROM .ATIONAL!RCHIVEOF#RIMINAL*USTICE$ATA )NTER UNIVERSITY#ONSORTIUMFOR0OLITICALAND3OCIAL 2ESEARCH 5NIVERSITYOF-ICHIGAN52,HTTPWWWICPSRUMICHEDU.!#$*ARCHIVEHTML



#RIMINALJUSTICEANDHEALTHDISPARITIES

MALES2ECENTLY THE"UREAUOF*USTICE3TATISTICSESTIMATEDTHATNEARLYONEINEVERY THREE"LACKMALESWOULDSERVETIMEINASTATEORFEDERALPRISONINTHEIRLIFETIME 4HE IMPACT OF THESE AND OTHER DISPROPORTIONS EVIDENT IN THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEMTAKEMANYFORMS BUTSOMECENTRALCONSEQUENCESFALLONTHEHEALTHOFMINORITY COMMUNITIES WITHTHEGREATESTIMPACTFALLINGONTHE!FRICAN!MERICANCOMMUNITY )N ATA-EETINGON-INORITY(EALTH$ISPARITIESSPONSOREDBYTHE.ATIONAL )NSTITUTEON$RUG!BUSE )GUCHIANDCOLLEAGUESOUTLINEDHOWTHEDISPROPORTIONATE ENTRY OF RACIAL AND ETHNIC MINORITIES INTO PRISON FOR FELONY DRUG OFFENSES MIGHT AFFECTTHEHEALTHANDWELL BEINGOFTHOSECOMMUNITIES)GUCHIANDCOLLEAGUESNOTED THATAFELONYDRUGCONVICTIONSIGNIlCANTLYDECREASES ACCESSTOJOBSANDRELATED HEALTHBENElTS ACCESSTOPUBLICHOUSINGDUETOPASSAGEOFLEGISLATIONIN SPRINGINGFROMAPOLICYINITIATIVETITLED/NE3TRIKEAND9OURE/UT ACCESSTOSOME HEALTHBENElTSSUCHASFOODSTAMPSDUETOPASSAGEOFTHE0ERSONAL2ESPONSIBILITY AND7ORK/PPORTUNITY2ECONCILIATION!CTOF027/2!  ACCESSTOMANY JOBS LICENSESPERMITSANDMILITARYSERVICEALSORESTRICTEDBY027/2! ACCESSTO lNANCIALSUPPORTFORHIGHEREDUCATIONRESTRICTEDBYLANGUAGEINCLUDEDINTHE(IGHER %DUCATION!MENDMENTSOFAND THERIGHTTOVOTEINMANYSTATES)GUCHIAND COLLEAGUESALSONOTETHATAFELONYDRUGCONVICTIONMIGHTAFFECTIMMIGRATIONSTATUS DUETOPASSAGEOFTHE)LLEGAL)MMIGRATION2EFORMAND)MMIGRATION2ESPONSIBILITY !CTOF !LLOFTHERESTRICTIONSTOSERVICESANDOPPORTUNITIESAREAPPLIEDAFTERTHEOFFENDER HASCOMPLETEDTIMEINPRISON3UCHRESTRICTIONSAPPEARTOHAVETHEPERVERSEEFFECTOF INCREASINGTHEPROBABILITYOFRELAPSEINTODRUGUSEANDULTIMATELYOFREINCARCERATION FOR WHICH THE PROBABILITY WAS ALREADY HIGH !T A MINIMUM SUCH RESTRICTIONS EXACERBATETHEIMPACTOFHEALTHDISPARITIESALREADYEVIDENTINTHECOMMUNITY AND CLEARLYHAVEANADVERSEEFFECTONTHEHEALTHANDWELLBEINGOFTHEOFFENDER THEFAMILY OFTHEOFFENDER ANDTHECOMMUNITYATLARGE

$ISPROPORTIONSAREALSO%VIDENTINTHE*UVENILE*USTICE3YSTEM 4HEDISPROPORTIONSINFELONYDRUGCONVICTIONSANDRELATEDPRISONENTRIESEVIDENTIN THEADULTCRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEMAREALSOEVIDENTINTHEJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEMn 3UBSTANCEABUSEANDDRUG RELATEDCRIMESAMONGYOUTHOFTENBRINGADOLESCENTAND TEENOFFENDERSINTOTHEJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEM!TITSBEST THEJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEM CANFUNCTIONASAMEANSOFGETTINGSUBSTANCE USINGANDOTHERYOUTHBACKONTRACK BYDIRECTINGJUVENILEOFFENDERSTOAPPROPRIATETREATMENTANDREHABILITATIONOPTIONS !TITSWORST THESYSTEMCANRESULTINHAPHAZARDANDSOMETIMESUNFAIRDECISIONS CONCERNINGYOUTHPLACEMENTORCONlNEMENTn /NEOFTHEMOSTTROUBLINGTRENDSINTHEJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEMTODAYISASETOF SIGNIlCANTDISPARITIESAPPARENTINTHESYSTEMSHANDLINGOF"LACKYOUTHSCOMPARED WITHITSHANDLINGOFNON (ISPANIC7HITEAND(ISPANICYOUTHS!CCORDINGTOARECENT REPORTFROMTHE/FlCEOF*UVENILE*USTICEAND$ELINQUENCY0REVENTION BETWEEN AND THERATIOOF"LACKTO7HITEJUVENILEDRUGOFFENDERSWASTO WITH DRUG OFFENSES ACCOUNTING FOR  OF ALL JUVENILE PLACEMENTS EXCLUDING TECHNICAL VIOLATORS !SOF/CTOBER APPROXIMATELYOFEVERYMALE"LACKJUVENILES WASINAJUVENILERESIDENTIALPLACEMENTFACILITY COMPAREDWITHAPPROXIMATELYOF

)GUCHI "ELL 2AMCHANDAND&AIN



EVERYMALE(ISPANICJUVENILESANDOFEVERYMALE7HITEJUVENILES-OREOVER BETWEENAND PRISONADMISSIONSFORJUVENILESUNDERTHEAGEOFINCREASED FOR"LACKMALES COMPAREDWITHFOR7HITEMALES )NSOMESTATES THEDISPROPORTIONSINMINORITYCONlNEMENTAREESPECIALLYSTRIKING $E#OMONOTESTHATIN3OUTH#AROLINA ALMOSTONEINTHREE"LACKMALESWERETAKEN INTOCUSTODYPRIORTOAGE ARATENINETIMESGREATERTHANTHATFOR7HITEMALESUNDER THEAGEOF4ABLELISTSTHESTATESWITHTHEGREATESTDISPROPORTIONSINCUMULATIVE PREVALENCERATESFOR"LACKAND7HITEYOUTHSTAKENINTOCUSTODYCALCULATEDFROM$E #OMO /NLYINONEOFTHESESTATES)DAHO WERE"LACKYOUTHSTAKENINTOCUSTODY ATASIGNIlCANTLYLOWERRATETHAN7HITEYOUTHS !NUMBEROFEXPLANATIONSHAVEBEENOFFEREDTOACCOUNTFORTHESEPRONOUNCED DISPARITIES3OMEPOSTULATETHATMINORITYYOUTHAREOVER REPRESENTEDINTHEJUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEM BECAUSE THEY COMMIT MORE CRIMES AND MORE SERIOUS CRIMESn /THERS POSTULATE MACRO LEVEL OR STRUCTURAL FACTORS &OR EXAMPLE 3AMPSON AND ,AUB DRAWINGFROM4ITLEAND#URRAN POSTULATEDTHATPERCEPTIONSOFSOCIALTHREAT hPROVOKEJEALOUSY ENVY ORPERSONALFEARAMONGELITES;P=v4HEYEXTENDEDTHIS NOTIONOFSOCIALTHREATTOINCLUDEPERCEPTIONSOFTHREATBYMAINSTREAM!MERICANS WHOTHEYHYPOTHESIZEDWERENEGATIVELYRESPONDINGTOTHEhSTEREOTYPEOFTHREATENING YOUNGBLACKMALESDEALINGDRUGSINPOORNEIGHBORHOODS;P=v4HEIRANALYSES INDICATEDTHATSTRUCTURALFACTORSSUCHASRACIALINEQUALITYANDUNDERCLASSPOVERTY AFFECTEDTHEWAYTHAT"LACKSWEREPROCESSEDTHROUGHTHEJUVENILECOURTS WITHBIASED OUTCOMESNOTEDINFORMALPETITIONING PREDISPOSITIONDETENTION ANDOUT OF HOME PLACEMENTDECISIONS ! NUMBER OF MICRO LEVEL STUDIES HAVE BEEN CONDUCTEDn 4O TAKE JUST ONE EXAMPLE "RIDGESAND3TEENFOUNDTHATPROBATIONOFlCERSRECOMMENDATIONSTO COURTSWERESIGNIlCANTLYMORELIKELYTOATTRIBUTE"LACKOFFENDERSBEHAVIORTOINTERNAL CAUSESIE EMOTIONALSTATEORINTENTION AND7HITESBEHAVIORTOEXTERNALCAUSES IE MITIGATINGENVIRONMENTALFACTOROREVENTS EVENWHENCONTROLLINGFORCRIMINAL ACTANDPRIORRECORD/NCEAJUVENILEISPLACEDINTHEJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEM ITISEASY TOSEEHOWTHEINCREASEDCRIMINALJUSTICESCRUTINY RELATEDSTIGMA ANDDEVIANTPEER CONTACTMIGHTINCREASETHEPROBABILITYOFCONTACTWITHTHEADULTCRIMINALJUSTICE SYSTEMANDITSCONSEQUENCES 4HEISSUEOFDISPROPORTIONATEMINORITYCONlNEMENT$-# ISNOTNEW)NDEED THE*UVENILE*USTICEAND$ELINQUENCY0REVENTION!CTOFEXPLICITLYACKNOWLEDGES THEPROBLEMANDEXTENDSTHECONCEPTTOINCLUDEDISPROPORTIONATEMINORITYCONTACT 4HEACTALSOSPECIlESlNANCIALPENALTIESINCENTIVESFORSTATE$-#REDUCTIONEFFORTS )N ADDITION THE /FlCE OF *UVENILE *USTICE AND $ELINQUENCY 0REVENTION /**$0 HOSTSA$-#WEB SITEANDRECOMMENDSlVEINTEGRATEDSTRATEGIESFORDEALINGWITH THEISSUE CONDUCTNEWRESEARCH ANALYZEDECISION MAKINGINTHESYSTEM ADVOCATEFORMINORITYYOUTH BUILDCONSTITUENCIESFORCHANGEAND DEVELOP COMMUNICATIONSTRATEGIES 7EAGREEWITHANDSUPPORTTHESEGLOBALPRIORITIES BUTWEALSOSUGGESTTHENEEDTO APPLYALLlVESTRATEGIESLOCALLYWITHINTHEFRAMEWORKOFA1UALITY!SSESSMENT1! APPROACHSUCHASTHOSEINCREASINGLYAPPLIEDBYTHEHEALTHCAREINDUSTRYn1UALITY !SSESSMENTAPPROACHESINTEGRATEALLOFTHE/**$0STRATEGIESOFFEREDABOVEANDMIGHT



#RIMINALJUSTICEANDHEALTHDISPARITIES

4ABLE 2!4)//&",!#+4/7()4%02%6!,%.#%2!4%3&/2-!,%3 5.$%2!'%4!+%.).4/34!4%#534/$9 3TATE









"LACK7HITE0REVALENCE2ATES

.EW*ERSEY .EW9ORK ,OUISIANA -ISSISSIPPI 'EORGIA #ONNECTICUT )DAHO )LLINOIS $ELAWARE

        

3OURCEFORDATAIN4ABLE$E#OMO 2%%STIMATINGTHEPREVALENCEOFJUVENILECUSTODYBYRACEAND GENDER#RIME$ELINQ 

BEUSEDTOPROVIDESTRUCTUREFOREFFORTSTOINCREASETRANSPARENCY ACCOUNTABILITY AND CONTINUOUSSYSTEMIMPROVEMENTINJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEMS

4AKINGA1UALITY!SSESSMENT!PPROACH 1UALITY!SSESSMENT1! APPROACHESPROVIDEASYSTEMATICMEANSFORBRINGINGGREATER TRANSPARENCYANDACCOUNTABILITYTOANORGANIZATIONORSYSTEM4HEMEASUREMENT AND ASSESSMENT OF QUALITY MAY INVOLVE STRUCTURES COMPONENTS PROCESSES OR OUTCOMESn (ALLMARKS OF A 1! APPROACH INCLUDE CLEARLY STATED POLICIES AND PROCEDURESDETERMINEDTHROUGHTHEINVOLVEMENTOFALLSTAKEHOLDERS THATCANBE USED TO PROVIDE ADMINISTRATIVE OVERSIGHT FORMULATION OF PERFORMANCE CRITERIA METRICS ANDBENCHMARKSCOLLECTIONOFRELEVANTDATATHATAREMADEWIDELYAVAILABLETO STAKEHOLDERSANDAREUSEDTOMAKEDECISIONSANDTOIDENTIFYAPPROPRIATEINTERVENTIONS ANDREPORTINGMEASURES INCLUDINGPERFORMANCEREPORTCARDS THATPROVIDEOBJECTIVE DATAABOUTTHESYSTEMSFUNCTIONINGTOSTAKEHOLDERSANDENSURETHATTHESYSTEMISHELD ACCOUNTABLE1UALITY!SSESSMENTAPPROACHESAREDElNEDMOREBYTHEIRPHILOSOPHY ANDAPPROACHTHANBYPRESCRIPTIONSTHEYMAKE /UR PRIMARY REASONS FOR SUGGESTING A 1! APPROACH ARE  1! APPROACHES EMPHASIZETHEPERSPECTIVEANDNEEDSOFTHECONSUMER 1!APPROACHESINTEGRATE ALLOFTHEGOALSDESCRIBEDABOVEBY/**$0AND 1!APPROACHESEMPHASIZEINPUT FROMALLSTAKEHOLDERSATALLLEVELS!LSOOFIMPORTANCE EFFORTSTOIMPLEMENTA1! APPROACHCANBEGINLOCALLY ANDATRELATIVELYLOWCOST"ELOW WEHIGHLIGHTAFEWREAL WORLDEXAMPLESDRAWNFROMTHEEXPERIENCESOFOURCO AUTHOR *AMES"ELL

4HE1!!PPROACH3OME2EAL7ORLD%XAMPLES 4HE7 (AYWOOD "URNS )NSTITUTE  DIRECTED BY *AMES "ELL IS WORKING WITH TEN COMMUNITIESSCATTEREDTHROUGHOUTTHECOUNTRYTOREDUCETHEOVER REPRESENTATIONOF

)GUCHI "ELL 2AMCHANDAND&AIN



YOUTHOFCOLORINJUVENILEJUSTICEFACILITIES!LTHOUGH)NSTITUTESTAFFHAVENOTSPECIlCALLY USEDTHETERM1UALITY!SSESSMENT THEIRPOLICIESANDPRACTICESBEARTHEHALLMARKSOF 1! INCLUDINGTHEINVOLVEMENTOFSTAKEHOLDERS EMPHASISONDATAGUIDINGINQUIRY ANDACTION ANDCONTINUINGEMPHASISONTHECLARIlCATIONOFPOLICIESANDPROCEDURES ATALLLEVELSINORDERTOREDUCE$-# &OR EXAMPLE "ELL AND COLLEAGUES NOTICED THAT "LACK FEMALE JUVENILES WERE DROPPINGOUTOFA3AN&RANCISCOGROUPHOMEATMUCHHIGHERRATESTHANANYOTHER SUB POPULATION)NTERVIEWSWITHYOUNGWOMENATTHESITEINDICATEDTHATTHEPROBLEM hHADTODOWITHHAIRv/NDAYONEOFPROGRAMENTRY ALLRESIDENTSRECEIVEDABOTTLEOF 0RELLSHAMPOOANDWEREINSTRUCTEDTOWASHTHEIRHAIRMOST"LACKFEMALESREFUSED SINCESHAMPOOINGWITH0RELLWASNOTAPPROPRIATEFORTHECAREOFTHEIRHAIR"ECAUSE REFUSALTOWASHONESHAIRTYPICALLYMEANTDISCHARGE MANYGIRLSWEREEXPELLEDFROM THEGROUPHOME/NCETHESOURCEOFTHEPROBLEMWASINVESTIGATEDANDDETERMINED THEHOMEIMPLEMENTEDNEW MORECULTURALLYSENSITIVEAPPROACHESANDSUCCEEDED INREDUCINGTHEDISPARITY (AYWARD"URNS)NSTITUTESTAFFIN3AN&RANCISCOALSONOTEDTHATAJUVENILEHALL SCREENINGTODETERMINEADOLESCENTSRISKOFOFFENDINGIFRETURNEDTOSOCIETYRESULTED IN"LACKSBEINGASSIGNEDTODETENTIONATADISPROPORTIONATELYHIGHRATE!DDITIONAL INVESTIGATIONS INDICATED THAT "LACK ADOLESCENTS WERE FAR MORE LIKELY THAN NON (ISPANIC7HITEOR(ISPANICADOLESCENTSTOBESENTTODETENTIONTHROUGHANOVERRIDE RECOMMENDATIONWHICHISREQUIREDTOSENDAYOUTHTODETENTIONWHENARISKSCOREDID NOTINDICATETHENEED !NAUDITOF"LACKYOUTHSRISKFORMSINDICATEDTHATHAD NEVERBEENlLLEDOUT PROVIDEDNOREASONFORREFERRAL ANDRECOMMENDED DETENTIONBECAUSEAPARENTCOULDNOTEASILYBELOCATED-OREOVER VIRTUALLYALLOFTHE OVERRIDESWERERELEASEDFROMDETENTIONATTHEJUDICIALHEARINGWITHINTHREEDAYS AT ACOSTTOTHESYSTEMOFDAYANDANINCREASEINPERCEPTIONSOFUNFAIRNESSON THEPARTOFTHOSEDETAINED/NCEITBECAMECLEARTHATMOSTOVERRIDESWEREUNCALLED FOR ANEWPOLICYWASIMPLEMENTEDTOESTABLISHANADMINISTRATIVEQUALITYCHECKBY REQUIRINGSUPERVISORAPPROVALOFALLOVERRIDES )N3AN*OSE #ALIFORNIA IMPROVEMENTSWEREINSTITUTEDINAJUVENILECOURTTOREDUCE THENUMBEROFADOLESCENTSWHOWEREROUTINELYBEINGDROPPEDOFFATTHECOURTBY POLICE4HECONCERNWASTHATPOLICEWEREDROPPINGADOLESCENTSOFFATTHEJUVENILE COURTWHETHERORNOTTHISWASAPPROPRIATEINANYINDIVIDUALCASE"ELLANDCOLLEAGUES WORKEDWITHTHEJUVENILECOURTANDTHEPOLICETOESTABLISHCLEAROPERATIONALCRITERIA FORPLACEMENTINTHEJUVENILEDETENTIONFACILITYANDDEVELOPEDACRITERIACARDTHAT POLICECOULDCARRYINTHEIRWALLETS4HECRITERIACARDPROVIDEDPHONENUMBERSAND PLACEMENT CRITERIA FOR ALTERNATIVE SETTINGS EG DRUG TREATMENT OR MENTAL HEALTH FACILITY TOASSISTPOLICEINIDENTIFYINGTHEBESTINTERVENTIONOPTION )N 3ANTA #RUZ #ALIFORNIA A REVIEW OF COURT RECORDS INDICATED THAT MINORITY JUVENILESWERESIGNIlCANTLYMORELIKELYTHANNON (ISPANIC7HITEOFFENDERSTOMISS THEIRJUDICIALHEARINGSINTHEDAILYMORNINGSESSIONSOFTHE.ORTH#OUNTYCOURT /N SITEINTERVIEWSREVEALEDTHATMOSTOFTHEMINORITYOFFENDERS"LACKAND(ISPANIC YOUTH WERELOCATEDATAJUVENILEFACILITYIN7ATSONVILLE #ALIFORNIA LOCATEDIN3OUTH #OUNTY ANDTHATTHEREWASNOEARLYMORNINGBUSSERVICEBETWEEN3OUTH#OUNTYAND .ORTH#OUNTY&URTHER THENEARESTBUSSTOPWASOVERAMILEFROMTHECOURTHOUSE

#RIMINALJUSTICEANDHEALTHDISPARITIES



ATTHETOPOFASTEEPHILL4OREMEDYTHEPROBLEM ANEWCOURTROOMWASOPENED IN3OUTH#OUNTY CLOSERTOTHEMINORITYADOLESCENTS/NCETHISRECOMMENDATION WAS IMPLEMENTED THE FAILURE TO SHOW RATE OF MINORITY ADOLESCENTS DECREASED SIGNIlCANTLY 4HE3ANTA#RUZ#OUNTY0ROBATION/FlCEREPORTEDTHATFROMn (ISPANIC JUVENILESMADEUPOFTHEJUVENILEHALLPOPULATIONWHILETHEIRCOUNTYPOPULATION REPRESENTATIONWASONLY!FTERIMPLEMENTATIONOF$-#REDUCTIONACTIVITIES BY"URNS)NSTITUTESTAFFSUCHASTHOSEDESCRIBEDABOVE THEPERCENTAGEOF(ISPANIC JUVENILESINJUVENILEHALLDROPPEDTOINANDINEARLY 7HILESUCHEXAMPLESANDANECDOTESSHOULDNOTBECONSTRUEDASSCIENTIlCEVIDENCE THEYDOAPPEARTOSUPPORTDEVELOPMENTANDTESTINGOFSYSTEMATIC1!APPROACHES ADDRESSINGDISPARITIESINTHEJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEM4HEDATA DRIVEN1!APPROACH SUPPORTSCONTINUOUSSYSTEMIMPROVEMENT INCREASESACCOUNTABILITY ANDIMPROVES OUTCOMES ALLOWINGDISPARITIESTOBEADDRESSEDWITHOUTTHEUSUALDESCENTINTOCHARGES OFDISCRIMINATION THEBUREAUCRACYOFDENIAL ANDTHEVICIOUSDOWNWARDSPIRALOFTEN OBSERVEDFORTHEJUVENILESINVOLVED !1!APPROACHWILLNOTSOLVEALLPROBLEMSINTHEJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEM)NFACT THE INITIALIMPLEMENTATIONOFSUCHANAPPROACHISLIKELYTOEXPOSESOMEOFTHESYSTEMS MORECHALLENGINGPROBLEMS(OWEVER ONLYIFSUCHPROBLEMSAREBROUGHTTOLIGHTAND INSPECTEDCANTHESYSTEMBEGINTOCHANGEINASIGNIlCANTANDLASTINGWAY

3UMMARY 7EHAVEPRESENTEDASNAPSHOTOFTHEREMARKABLEDISPROPORTIONSEVIDENTINBOTH THEADULTANDJUVENILEJUSTICESYSTEMSTHATAPPEARTOHAVEBEENEXACERBATEDBYTHE 7ARON$RUGS4HEDISPROPORTIONSEVIDENTINRATESOFMINORITYCONlNEMENTARE JUSTTHEPROLOGUEOFALARGERPROBLEMASRECIDIVISMRATESAREEXTREMELYHIGHAFTER RELEASE LEADINGTOLIFE LONGINVOLVEMENTWITHTHECRIMINALJUSTICESYSTEMFORMANY 7EHAVEOUTLINEDHOWTHESEDISPROPORTIONSMIGHTAFFECTTHEHEALTHANDWELL BEING OF COMMUNITIES OF COLOR AND WE DISCUSSED ONE POSSIBLE MODEL FOR IDENTIFYING AND ROOTING OUT THE SYSTEMIC FACTORS THAT MIGHT CONTRIBUTE TO THE PROBLEM /UR EMPHASIS HOWEVER ISONTHENEEDTOINTRODUCEQUALITYASSESSMENTAPPROACHESTHAT INVOLVE MULTIPLE STAKEHOLDERS EMPHASIZE A DATA DRIVEN APPROACH OPEN UP THESE SYSTEMSFORINTERNALANDEXTERNALMONITORING ANDTHATALLOWFORSYSTEMATICREVIEW OFDISPROPORTIONSANDTHEIRCAUSES

!CKNOWLEDGMENT 4HISPAPERWASSUPPORTEDINPARTBYA(EALTH$ISPARITIES3UPPLEMENTALGRANTFROM THE.ATIONAL)NSTITUTEON$RUG!BUSE2$! AWARDEDTO)GUCHI

.OTES  

"UREAUOF*USTICE3TATISTICS"*3 .ATIONAL#ORRECTIONS2EPORTING0ROGRAM 7ASHINGTON $#53$EPARTMENTOF*USTICE$/* n )GUCHI-9 &AIN40ROJECTMEMORANDUM0ERCAPITAESTIMATESOFPRISONENTRYFORDRUG ANDVIOLENTOFFENDERS n3ANTA-ONICA #!2!.$0-n 

)GUCHI "ELL 2AMCHANDAND&AIN            



    

 







"ONZAR400REVALENCEOFIMPRISONMENTINTHE53POPULATION n0UB.#*  7ASHINGTON $#"*3  )GUCHI-9 ,ONDON*! &ORGE.' ETAL%LEMENTSOFWELL BEINGAFFECTEDBYCRIMINALIZING THEDRUGUSER!NOVERVIEW0UBLIC(EALTH2EP3UPPL 3n ,ANGAN0! ,EVIN$*2ECIDIVISMOFPRISONERSRELEASEDIN0UB.#* 7ASHINGTON $#53"*3 *UNE -C'ARRELL%&4RENDSINRACIALDISPROPORTIONALITYINJUVENILECOURTPROCESSINGn #RIME$ELINQ*AN n 3MITH"#HILDRENINCUSTODYTWENTY YEARTRENDSINJUVENILEDETENTION CORRECTIONAL ANDSHELTERFACILITIES#RIME$ELINQ/CT n 7ORDES- *ONES3-4RENDSINJUVENILEDETENTIONANDSTEPSTOWARDREFORM#RIME $ELINQ/CT n ,EIBER-*$ISPROPORTIONATEMINORITYCONlNEMENT$-# OFYOUTHANANALYSISOF STATEANDFEDERALEFFORTSTOADDRESSTHISISSUE#RIME$ELINQ*AN n ,EIBER-* -ACK+94HEINDIVIDUALANDJOINTEFFECTSOFRACE GENDER ANDFAMILYSTATUS ONJUVENILEJUSTICEDECISION MAKING*2ES#RIME$ELINQ&EB n ,EIBER-* 3TAIRS*-2ACE CONTEXTS ANDTHEUSEOFINTAKEDIVERSION*2ES#RIME$ELINQ &EB n 3ICKMUND - *UVENILES IN #ORRECTIONS 0UB .#*  7ASHINGTON $# $/* /FlCEOF*UVENILE*USTICEAND$ELINQUENCY0REVENTION  $E#OMO2%%STIMATINGTHEPREVALENCEOFJUVENILECUSTODYBYRACEANDGENDER#RIME $ELINQn %NGEN 2, 3TEEN 3 "RIDGES '3 2ACIAL DISPARITIES IN THE PUNISHMENT OF YOUTH A THEORETICALANDEMPIRICALASSESSMENTOFTHELITERATURE3OC0ROBL-AY n  "RIDGES '3 #RUTCHFIELD 2$ 3IMPSON %% #RIME SOCIAL STRUCTURE AND CRIMINAL PUNISHMENTWHITEANDNONWHITERATESOFIMPRISONMENT3OC0ROBL/CT n  3AMPSON2 ,AUB*3TRUCTURALVARIATIONSINJUVENILECOURTPROCESSING)NEQUALITY AND UNDERCLASS ANDSOCIALCONTROL,AW3OC2EVn 4ITTLE#2 #URRAN$!#ONTINGENCIESFORDISPOSITIONALDISPARITIESINCRIMINALJUSTICE 3OC&ORCES3EP n 0OPE#% &EYERHERM7(-INORITYSTATUSANDJUVENILEJUSTICEPROCESSINGANASSESSMENT OFTHERESEARCHLITERATURE0ART) #RIM*UST!BSTRn 0OPE#% &EYERHERM7(-INORITYSTATUSANDJUVENILEJUSTICEPROCESSING!NASSESSMENT OFTHERESEARCHLITERATURE0ART)) #RIM*UST!BSTRn "RIDGES '3 3TEEN 3 2ACIAL DISPARITIES IN OFlCIAL ASSESSMENTS OF JUVENILE OFFENDERS !TTRIBUTIONAL STEREOTYPES AS MEDIATING MECHANISMS!M 3OCIOL 2EV n  $ISHION4* -C#ORD* 0OULIN&7HENINTERVENTIONSHARM0EERGROUPSANDPROBLEM BEHAVIOR!M0SYCHOL3EP n (SIA ( ! DISPROPORTIONATE MINORITY CONTACT $-# CHRONOLOGY  TO DATE 7ASHINGTON $#$/* /FlCEOF*UVENILE*USTICEAND$ELINQUENCY0REVENTION  !VAILABLEATHTTPOJJDPNCJRSORGDMCABOUTCHRONOLOGYHTML (SIA (- "RIDGES '3 -C(ALE 2 $ISPROPORTIONATE -INORITY #ONlNEMENT  5PDATE 0UB .#*  7ASHINGTON $# $/* /FlCE OF *UVENILE *USTICE AND $ELINQUENCY0REVENTION  "ERWICK$-#ONTINUOUSIMPROVEMENTASANIDEALINHEALTHCARE.EW%NGL*-ED *AN n



 

 



#RIMINALJUSTICEANDHEALTHDISPARITIES ,AFFEL' "LUMENTHAL$4HECASEFORUSINGINDUSTRIALQUALITYMANAGEMENTSCIENCEIN HEALTHCAREORGANIZATIONS*!-!.OV n 3CHUSTER-! -C'LYNN%! 0HAM#" ETAL4HEQUALITYOFHEALTHCAREINTHE5NITED 3TATES!REVIEWOFARTICLESSINCE)N)NSTITUTEOF-EDICINE#ROSSINGTHEQUALITY CHASMANEWHEALTHSYSTEMFORTHESTCENTURY7ASHINGTON $#.ATIONAL!CADEMY 0RESS n $ONABEDIAN!4HEDElNITIONOFQUALITYANDAPPROACHESTOITSASSESSMENT!NN!RBOR -)(EALTH!DMINISTRATION0RESS  7(AYWOOD"URNS)NSTITUTE2EDUCINGDISPROPORTIONALITYLOCALLY3AN&RANCISCO #!7 (AYWOOD"URNS)NSTITUTE !VAILABLEATHTTPWWWBURNSINSTITUTEORGREDUCING HTML #OX*!!DDRESSINGDISPROPORTIONATEMINORITYREPRESENTATIONWITHINTHEJUVENILEJUSTICE SYSTEM 3ANTA #RUZ #! "UILDING "LOCKS FOR9OUTH !VAILABLE AT HTTPWWW BUILDINGBLOCKSFORYOUTHORGISSUESDMCADDRESSINGDMCHTML