Heras Escribano, M. (2014) \"Razón y experiencia: El debate McDowell-Dreyfus\". Análisis Filosófico, 34 (2): 203-227

The following paper provides a critical analysis of "Mind, Reason and Being-in-the-world: The McDowell-Dreyfus Debate", edited by Josep K. Schear (2013). First I offer a brief introduction to the  proposals of both authors in order to account for perception and its relation to rationality. After that, I will evaluate the two arguments of Dreyfus (expertise and the merging argument) against McDowell’s main thesis by which there is no gap between experience and reason. Also, I will pay special attention to the different notions of perceptual content and epistemic access that both authors endorse.